ԻՆՉՊԵՍ ԴԱՌՆԱԼ ՈՍՏԻԿԱՆ
ԻՆՉՊԵՍ ԴԱՌՆԱԼ ՓՐԿԱՐԱՐ

Վարդանյան Հայկ 022

ISSUES OF SUBJECT-MATTER JURISDICTION IN DISPUTES ARISING FROM THE EXERCISE OF DELEGATED PUBLIC AUTHORITY POWERS IN THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA

VARDANYAN HAYK

Deputy Director of the “International Research Center” LLC, Candidate for Inclusion in the List of Candidates for Administrative Judges of the Academy of Justice of the Republic of Armenia, advocate (Attorney) of the chamber of advocates of the Republic of Armenia

 

ABSTRACT

Purpose.The purpose of this study is to examine the legal nature of legal relationships arising in the context of the delegation of public authority powers in the Republic of Armenia, the issues related to the delimitation of subject-matter jurisdiction between administrative and civil proceedings, their impact on the exercise of the right to effective judicial protection, and to assess the applicability of the “Single Door to Justice” concept as a tool for the systemic resolution of existing problems.

Methods.The study employs legal-dogmatic, systemic, comparative legal, and case-law analysis methods. The research examines the provisions of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia, the Administrative Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia, the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia, and sector-specific legislation, as well as the decisions of the Constitutional Court and the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia. In addition, the experience of several European states regarding judicial review within the framework of administrative justice over non-state entities exercising public functions is analyzed.

Results.The study demonstrates that the exercise of public authority powers should be assessed not on the basis of the organizational and legal form of the entity concerned, but rather on the nature of the function performed. It is substantiated that the exercise of delegated public powers by state non-commercial organizations, self-regulatory organizations, and other legal entities established by law may give rise to public-law relations, and that disputes arising from such relations should be adjudicated within the framework of administrative proceedings. The research also reveals that differing approaches adopted by administrative and civil courts in assessing identical legal relationships lead to the transfer of cases between jurisdictions, procedural delays, and risks to the effective realization of the right to judicial protection.

Conclusions.The author concludes that the current legal framework and judicial practice do not fully ensure the effectiveness and accessibility of judicial protection. The study proposes the implementation of the “Single Door to Justice” principle, whereby individuals would access the judicial system through a unified point of entry, while the allocation of cases according to judicial specialization would take place within the judicial system itself. Such an approach would reduce disputes concerning jurisdiction, eliminate the risk of choosing the wrong court, and contribute to enhancing the accessibility, promptness, and effectiveness of justice.

Key words: public law, private law, administrative justice, subject-matter jurisdiction, delegation of public authority powers, effective judicial protection, transfer of cases, Single Door to Justice principle.

  

DOI:https://10.63925/18294847-2026.blj22-14

PDF