ԻՆՉՊԵՍ ԴԱՌՆԱԼ ՈՍՏԻԿԱՆ
ԻՆՉՊԵՍ ԴԱՌՆԱԼ ՓՐԿԱՐԱՐ

Մինասյան Սմբատ 022

 

LEGAL APPROACHES OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS TO THE PRINCIPLES OF LEGAL CERTAINTY

 

 

MINASYAN  SMBAT

 Applicant at the Chair of Law, Political Science and International Relations,

Eurasia International University,
Member of the Chamber of Advocates of the Republic of Armenia

 

Abstract․ This scholarly article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the principle of legal certainty as a fundamental component of the rule of law and constitutional statehood. The research examines the formation of this principle within European Union law, beginning with the Commission v Italy case, as well as its subsequent development in the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights.

The study demonstrates that legal certainty presupposes clarity, accessibility, and foreseeability of legal norms, enabling individuals to understand their rights and obligations and to anticipate legal consequences. These standards have been elaborated in key judicial practice, particularly in cases such as The Sunday Times v. the United Kingdom (No. 1), Malone v. the United Kingdom, and Busuioc v. Moldova.

Special attention is given to the principle of the finality of judicial decisions (res judicata), which serves as a guarantee of legal stability and the right to a fair trial. This aspect has been significantly developed in cases such as Brumărescu v. Romania and Ponomaryov v. Ukraine.

The article also addresses the doctrine of legitimate expectations, limitations on the retroactive effect of legal norms, and the scope of discretionary powers of public authorities, emphasizing that such powers must be exercised within clearly defined legal frameworks to prevent arbitrariness.

The study concludes that the principle of legal certainty constitutes an integral element of the constitutional order of states. It manifests itself both in the content of legal norms and in their practical application, ensuring the stability of legal relations, public trust, and the effective protection of human rights, thereby serving as a cornerstone of modern democratic governance.

 Key words: legal certainty, rule of law, “prescribed by law” requirement, foreseeability, res judicata, legitimate expectations, judicial practice, European Court of Human Rights․

 

DOI:https://10.63925/18294847-2026.blj22-07

PDF